Or by a fan of Giffin who finally came to her senses and deleted her ragey rants to a 1 star review:ĬOME ON! Emily Giffin, your book was #2 on the NYT list. FOR EXAMPLE, Amazon deleted her husband’s comment, which was the very first comment to the review. When you delete a comment on Amazon, it leaves a trail. Worse? Now Giffin is claiming that the reviewer insulted her husband first and he just responded. More fans go to attack readers/reviewers, leaving negative diatribes on every negative review for Giffin’s latest release. Giffin giggles about it on Facebook and Twitter. Really? An “avid reader” that has written one review in their entire existence on amazon. The reader in question a) read and liked previous Giffin books and b) ACTUALLY BOUGHT THE BOOK from Amazon (as noted by the Amazon Verified Purchase badge on her review). This review enrages Giffin’s husband and he leaves the following comment:

This reader did not like the book and all the comments are directed to the book. Giffin’s last books have been a disappointment and this one was no different. I also found that Giffin put a very negative spin on adoption. Also I found both characters to be very unlikable. However, telling the story from two points of view, Marianne and Kirby, led there to be little depth to either character. Where We Belong had the ability to be a great story. I have read all of Emily Giffin’s books, and have found that her last few books are getting worse and worse. Nice people don’t call random readers psycho for an entirely mild review. Giffin, allegedly the nicest person ever per her fans, chortled over the fact that her husband called a reader “psycho” on Amazon and then encouraged, via Facebook and Twitter, her fans to go forth and engage in the same behavior. First up, we have Emily Giffin - pretty, successful, happily married Emily Giffin. Jane Publishing News Author Reader Relationship / bundling / Intellectual Property Issues / Navy SEALs 140 Commentsįorgive me, but I feel a bit irritable and thus my commentary on today’s news might have a slight edge. AugThursday News: Emily Giffin stirs up a sh!storm US Navy SEAL reveals all (and not in a good way) Katherine Hawkins’ cover appropriated by another author

Something Borrowed by Emily Giffin